High Manganese Austenitic Steels for Cryogenic Applications

خلاصات:

Martensitic high nitrogen stainless steels are particularly interesting because they typically exhibit high strength and ductility, good corrosion resistance and reduced grain boundary sensitization.
Nitrogen, when used as an additive in stainless steels can increase the austenitic phase range, decrease the formation of unwanted ferrite and at the same time help refine carbide to enhance strength.

As the name suggests, high-Mn steels are based on alloying Fe with a large amount of Mn (≥12 wt%). This makes the Fe-Mn equilibrium phase diagram an excellent starting point to understand their behavior. Figure 1 presents the equilibrium phase diagram of the Fe-Mn system. As can be seen, increasing Mn content significantly expands the austenite (γ) phase field. High temperature ferrite (δ) formation is suppressed by an addition of approximately 12-13 wt% Mn, indicating that alloys with this amount of manganese or more will exhibit fully austenitic solidification from high temperature. Another feature of interest in the Fe-Mn system is that the two phase region separating liquid (L) and austenite (γ) is quite narrow, suggesting that Mn does not segregate strongly during solidification. Estimating the partition ratio from the diagram itself gives a value of approximately 0.75. Although slightly outside of the data presented in Figure 1, a eutectoid reaction exists in the system at 255°C and 43 wt% Mn; γ→αFe+αMn. From a practical standpoint, the high-Mn alloys which are discussed here would not demonstrate any low temperature ferrite (αFe) formation during typical cooling conditions because of limited diffusion rates.



Figure 1: Fe-Mn equilibrium phase diagram

High manganese austenitic steels have been widely studied for their corresponding outstanding tensile strength and ductility. Certain high Mn austenitic steels have also been investigated for cryogenic applications. Koyama et al. studied the effects of temperature on the tensile properties of Fe-17Mn-0.6C steels and discovered that the uniform tensile elongation deteriorated as the deformation temperature decreased from room temperature to −100°C. The lower ductility was attributed to an increase in the amount of ε-martensite plates. This suggestion was supported by the observation that an addition of elements such as carbon, which suppressed the formation of ε-martensite, improved the cryogenic tensile ductility.

Therefore, it has been suggested that the reduction number of ε-martensite plates is a key factor for the cryogenic tensile ductility improvement of high Mn steels. One way for the number of ε-martensite plates to be suppressed is through austenite grain size refinement. Takaki et al. investigated the grain size effects on ε-martensite formation in Fe-15Mn alloys and discovered that when the grain size was below 10 µm, the ε-martensite transformation was almost suppressed. In a quite recent study, it was demonstrated that Fe-17Mn-0.6C alloys with coarse grain sizes (10–37 µm) demonstrated a brittle fracture at −150°C due to ε-martensite formation. In contrast, this embrittlement was suppressed by grain refinement to 3.5 µm. The formation of ε-martensite could also be suppressed by an increase in the Mn content. Tomota et al. demonstrated that, regarding the binary Fe-Mn system, when the Mn content was increased to 36%, no ε-martensite was observed in the tensile tested samples at room temperature, whereas only 4.2% of ε-martensite was formed following tensile deformation to a strain value exceeding 60% at the liquid nitrogen temperature. Fe-34.5Mn-0.04C steels are recently developed steels with potential applications at low temperatures.

Among 9% nickel steel, austenitic steel, aluminium alloy and austenitic Fe-Ni alloy that are materials applicable to LNG tanks, the three except for 9% nickel steel have a FCC crystal structure. Metallic materials with FCC structure do not show the property of ductile-brittle transition unlike those with common Body-Centered Cubic (BCC) structure. Thus, they maintain high toughness also at cryogenic temperatures. An exception is the 9% nickel steel, which has the residual FCC structure with a basis of Body-Centered Tetragonal (BCT) structure due to a special heating process that ensures toughness at cryogenic temperatures.

Alloy steel with FCC crystal structure is referred to as austenitic steel. Types of austenitic steel are nickel-based austenitic stainless steel such as types 304, 304L, 316, 316L, 321 and 347. Since the 1970s, comprehensive studies on austenitic steel for cryogenic applications based on manganese have been actively carried out. Recently, high manganese austenitic steel for cryogenic service (hereinafter referred to as “high Mn steel”) has been developed as an alternative that overcomes the disadvantage of FCC-structured metallic materials, namely low yield strength, and leverages the economic feasibility of manganese. Chemical composition of high Mn steel is registered in Korean industrial standards (KS-D-3031) as follows:



Table 1: Chemical compositions of high Mn steel (wt%)

Mechanical properties of high Mn steel were tested in accordance with international standard procedures as seen in Table 2. They were clarified through a comparison with other materials used for LNG tanks shown in Table 3. Particularly, Type 304 was chosen to represent austenitic stainless steel.



Table 2: Mechanical test items for high Mn steel



Table 3: Specifications of 5 different cryogenic materials

In Figure 1(a) is showed, yield strength of high Mn steel. As can be seen the yield stress is between those of Type 304 (equivalent to STS 304 in Korean Standards) and 9% nickel steel. In terms of ultimate tensile strength, it shows superiority over every type of metallic material in comparison. High Mn Steel recorded an elongation of around 80% of that of Type 304 and around 1.8-fold of that of 9% nickel steel. (a) Comparison with other cryogenic (b) Variation with respect to temperature Materials (25°C) Figure 1(b) shows the yield strength and ultimate tensile strength of high Mn steel increase monotonically and its elongation decreases, as test temperature decreases.



Figure 2: Stress-Strain curves of high Mn steel - (a) Comparison with other cryogenic materials (25°C) (b) Variation with respect to temperature


References

1. B. James Sutton: Solidification Behavior and Hot Cracking Susceptibility of High Manganese Steel Weld Metals, The Ohio State University, 2013;

2. Y. Wang, B. Shi, Y. He, H. Zhang, Y. Peng, T. Wang: A Fine Grain, High Mn Steel with Excellent Cryogenic Temperature Properties and Corresponding Constitutive Behaviour, Materials 2018, 11, 253; doi:10.3390/ma11020253;

3. Suitability of High manganese austenitic steel for cryogenic service and development of any necessary amendments to the IGC code and IGF code 2016, Accessed NOV 2018.

ابحث في قاعدة معلومات

ادخل عبارة لتبحث عنها:

بحث بِـ:

الوثيقة الكاملة
الكلمات المفاتيح

ترويسات
خلاصات

The Total Materia Extended Range includes a unique collection of stress-strain curves and diagrams for calculations in the plastic range for thousands of metal alloys, heat treatments and working temperatures. Both true and engineering stress curves are given for various strain rates where applicable.

Finding a stress-strain graph in the database is simple and takes only seconds.

Enter the material of interest into the quick search field. You can optionally narrow your search by specifying the country/standard of choice in the designated field and click Search.

solution img

After selecting the material of interest to you, click on the Stress-Strain diagrams link to view data for the selected material. The number of available stress-strain diagrams is displayed in brackets next to the link.

solution img

Because Total Materia stress-strain curves are neutral across standard specifications, you can review stress-strain diagrams by clicking the appropriate link for any of the subgroups.

Besides the stress-strain curves at different temperatures, stress and strain data are given in a tabular format which is convenient for copying to, for example, a CAE software.

solution img

It is also possible to view stress-strain curves and data for other working temperatures.

To do this, simply insert a new temperature into the ‘Enter temperature’ field within the defined range.

After clicking the Calculate button, a new curve is plotted and values in the table now correspond to the temperature you have defined. See example below for 250°C.

solution img

For you’re a chance to take a test drive of the Total Materia database, we invite you to join a community of over 150,000 registered users through the Total Materia Free Demo.