Welding Ultra-High-Strength Steels

---

Introduction to Ultra-High-Strength Steels

The term high-strength steel commonly refers to all steels beyond mild low-carbon varieties. Ultra-high-strength steels (UHSS) or super alloys specifically designate those with yield strengths exceeding 560 MPa. These advanced materials play critical roles in applications requiring exceptional strength-to-weight ratios and performance under extreme conditions.

The following categories comprise the ultra-high-strength steel family:

• Medium-carbon low-alloy hardenable steels
• Medium-alloy hardenable or tool and die steels
• High-alloy hardenable steels
• High-nickel maraging steels
• Martensitic stainless steels
• Semi-austenitic precipitation-hardenable stainless steels

Welding Medium-Carbon Low-Alloy Hardenable Steels

AISI 4130, 4140, 4340, and AMS 6434 steels represent the most widely used medium-carbon low-alloy hardenable steels. These materials achieve their exceptional strength through heat treatment to full martensitic microstructure, followed by tempering to enhance ductility and toughness. The tempering temperature significantly impacts the final strength levels. Carbon content is maintained at the minimum level necessary to achieve required strength properties, while impurities are strictly controlled through high-quality melting and refining processes.

These steels are available in various forms including sheets, bars, tubing, and light plate. While mechanical cutting is preferred, flame cutting can be performed with 316°C preheat. Flame-cut components should undergo annealing before additional processing to mitigate edge hardness.

Welding considerations include:

• Welding should only be performed when materials are in annealed or normalized condition
• Post-weld heat treatment is required to achieve desired strength properties
• Suitable welding processes include gas tungsten arc (GTAW), gas metal arc (GMAW), shielded metal arc (SMAW), and gas welding
• Filler metal composition must match base metal response to heat treatment
• Relatively high preheat and interpass temperatures (approximately 316°C) prevent brittleness and cracking
• Complex weldments require immediate post-weld heat treatment

Aircraft engine components, tubular aircraft frames, and racing car frames frequently utilize AISI 4130 tubing. Such structures typically remain as-welded without post-weld heat treatment.

Welding Medium-Alloy Hardenable Steels

Medium-alloy hardenable steels serve ultra-high-strength structural applications primarily in aerospace industries. These materials feature low-to-medium carbon content while providing excellent fracture toughness at high strength levels. Their air-hardening characteristics reduce distortion compared to more aggressive quenching methods. This category includes hot work die steels and 5Cr-Mo-V aircraft quality steels, available as forging billets, bars, sheet, strip, and plate.

Another important variant is the medium-alloy quenched and tempered HY 130/150 steel used in submarines, aerospace components, and pressure vessels. These plate products offer superior notch toughness at 0°C and below, with significantly lower carbon content than other grades in this classification.

Fabrication requirements include:

• Mandatory 316°C preheat before flame cutting aircraft quality steels due to their air-hardening properties
• Immediate post-cutting annealing to prevent brittle edge layers prone to cracking
• Welding only in annealed condition with 316°C preheat maintained throughout welding
• Slow cooling through post-heating or furnace cooling
• Stress relief at 704°C followed by air cooling to achieve fully tempered microstructure
• Annealing after welding prior to final heat treatment
• Matching filler metal composition to base metal
• Primary use of GTAW and GMAW processes, with SMAW, plasma arc, and electron beam welding as alternatives

For HY 130/150 steels, welding typically employs SMAW, GMAW, or submerged arc welding (SAW). Filler metals must provide equivalent strength to the base material, and all processes must maintain low-hydrogen or hydrogen-free conditions. E-13018 type low-hydrogen electrodes are recommended for SMAW, with careful attention to proper storage. For other processes, gas dryness and flux condition are critical considerations.

Proper heat input-output balance maintains yield strength and toughness. Preheating at minimum 38°C for thin materials and higher temperatures for thicker sections is essential. Heat input should avoid overheating adjacent base metal while providing sufficient heat output to maintain proper microstructure in the heat-affected zone. Properly executed joints typically achieve base metal performance levels without post-weld heat treatment.

Welding High-Alloy Hardenable Steels

High-alloy hardenable steels achieve exceptional strength—approximately 1240 MPa yield strength—through conventional hardening and tempering heat treatments. Despite their high strength, these materials maintain impressive toughness with minimal carbon content (typically around 0.20%). Their relatively high nickel and cobalt content (hence the alternative name "9 Ni-4 Co steels") along with other carefully selected alloying elements contribute to their remarkable properties.

Welding these steels typically occurs in the quenched and tempered condition using the GTAW process. Post-weld heat treatment is generally unnecessary, but filler metal must precisely match base metal composition.

Welding High-Nickel Maraging Steels

Maraging steels combine ultra-high strength with exceptional fracture toughness while maintaining formability, weldability, and straightforward heat treatment requirements. Distinguished by high nickel (18%, 20%, or 25%) and low carbon content, these steels derive their name and properties from a unique heat treatment called "maraging." These materials are available as sheet, forging billets, bars, strip, plate, and in some cases, tubing.

The maraging process involves heating the steel to 482°C and cooling to room temperature, during which all austenite transforms to martensite. A precise three-hour holding time at 482°C is critical, as strength development occurs during aging in the martensitic state.

Fabrication considerations include:

• Materials are supplied in soft or annealed condition, permitting cold working
• While flame cutting is possible, plasma arc cutting is preferred
• GTAW and GMAW are primary welding processes, with SMAW and SAW possible using specialized consumables
• Filler metal must match base metal composition with high purity and low carbon content
• Neither preheat nor postheat is required
• Post-weld maraging heat treatment produces extremely high-strength joints

Welding Martensitic Stainless Steels

Straight chromium martensitic stainless steels, typified by AISI 420, contain 12-14% chromium and up to 0.35% carbon, combining corrosion resistance with high strength. These versatile materials serve applications like jet engine compressor and turbine blades where moderate corrosion resistance and high strength are essential. Available as sheet, strip, tubing, plate, and castings, they can be heat treated to yield strengths approaching 1750 MPa.

Fabrication guidelines include:

• Flame cutting using powder systems designed for stainless steels or oxy-arc processes
• Flame cutting should be performed in annealed condition with 316°C preheat due to air-hardening characteristics
• Post-cutting annealing restores softness and ductility
• Cold working is possible in annealed condition
• Welding can occur in annealed or fully hardened states, typically without preheat or postheat
• GTAW is the preferred welding process
• Filler metal must match base metal composition
• Post-weld annealing followed by heat treatment achieves desired strength

Welding Semi-austenitic Precipitation-Hardenable Stainless Steels

Semi-austenitic precipitation-hardenable stainless steels, also known as PH steels, are chrome-nickel alloys that remain ductile in annealed conditions but can be hardened to exceptional strength through specialized heat treatment. In the annealed state, these austenitic materials readily accommodate cold working. Their remarkable strength results from a two-stage hardening process: austenite transformation to martensite followed by precipitate formation within the martensite.

Heat treatment for these steels involves heating annealed material to 927-954°C, followed by tempering or aging between 454-593°C. They are available as billets, sheets, tubing, and plates.

Welding considerations include:

• Flame cutting is not recommended
• GTAW and GMAW are primary welding processes, with SMAW rarely used
• Filler metal must match base metal composition
• No preheat or postheat required when welding in annealed condition
• Post-weld heat treatment is necessary to develop optimal strength
• Joint efficiency below 100% due to strength loss in heat-affected zones heated above aging temperature
• Extra reinforcement required for full-strength joints
• Brazing is also viable using nickel alloy filler metals

Quality Considerations for Ultra-High-Strength Steel Welding

When welding any ultra-high-strength steel, quality standards must be exceptionally rigorous. Complete root fusion is essential, and defects like undercut or stress risers must be eliminated. Weld metal should be entirely free from porosity, and any form of cracking is unacceptable. All necessary precautions must be implemented to ensure the highest possible weld quality for these critical applications.