Welding of Dissimilar Metals

---

Understanding Dissimilar Metal Welding: Fundamentals

The need for joining dissimilar metals arises from various industrial applications where different material properties are required within the same weldment. These applications include mechanical wear resistance, high-temperature performance, and specialized property requirements in different sections of the same component.

A successful dissimilar metal weld must achieve strength equal to or greater than the weaker of the two metals being joined, with sufficient tensile strength and ductility to prevent weld failure. This can be accomplished using various metals and welding processes, each selected based on specific application requirements.

Key Factors Affecting Dissimilar Metal Welding

Transition Zone Characteristics

The success of dissimilar metal welding largely depends on the transition zone between the metals and the formation of intermetallic compounds. Phase diagram analysis of the two metals is crucial for fusion welding processes. Successful joints are possible when there is mutual solubility between the metals; poor or no solubility typically results in unsuccessful joints.

Intermetallic Compound Properties

The properties of intermetallic compounds formed between dissimilar metals must be carefully evaluated for crack sensitivity, ductility, corrosion resistance, and microstructural characteristics. In some cases, a third metal that is soluble with both base metals may be required to achieve a successful joint.

Thermal Considerations

Several thermal factors significantly impact weld quality, including coefficient of thermal expansion differences between materials, varying melting temperatures of the metals, heat input requirements, and thermal conductivity variations.

Electrochemical Compatibility

The relative positions of metals on the electrochemical scale indicate potential corrosion susceptibility at the intermetallic zone. Metals far apart on this scale may experience severe corrosion issues.

Advanced Welding Processes and Techniques

Transition Material Applications

In certain cases, successful joints require transition materials between dissimilar metals. For example, when welding copper to steel, nickel serves as an effective intermediate metal due to its solubility with both materials. This can be achieved through direct nickel piece insertion or nickel alloy buttering or surfacing on steel.

Composite Insert Technology

Composite inserts provide an effective solution for joining dissimilar metals. These inserts are created using specialized welding processes that minimize heat input and associated complications.

Specialized Welding Processes

Modern welding methods include ultrasonic welding for thin materials, friction welding, high-frequency resistance welding, electron beam welding, and laser beam welding. Each offers specific advantages for dissimilar metal joining.

Explosion Welding

This process is suitable for joining incompatible metals with minimal heat input and no heat-affected zone, creating a characteristic sine wave interface pattern.

Cold Welding

This technique avoids heat-affected zones and allows minimal base metal mixing, making it ideal for aluminum-copper joints.

Ultrasonic Welding

Ultrasonic welding presents a unique solution for dissimilar metal joining, generating minimal heat at the weld joint. This process is particularly effective for thin materials and small parts, where traditional welding methods might prove challenging.

Friction Welding

Friction welding excels in creating composite transition inserts and joining dissimilar metals directly. The process successfully joins various metal combinations, including steel to copper base alloys, steel to aluminum, and stainless to nickel base alloys. Its effectiveness stems from minimal base metal heating, where any melted material is expelled from the joint, resulting in minimal intermetallic formation and a small heat-affected zone.

High-Frequency Resistance Welding

This widely adopted process concentrates heat precisely on the joining surfaces. The combination of focused heat and applied pressure creates strong welds between dissimilar materials. The process demonstrates particular success in joining copper to steel at high production speeds.

Diffusion and Percussion Welding

Diffusion welding has found significant application in aerospace manufacturing for dissimilar metals. Percussion welding, while limited to wires and small parts, offers precise control for specific applications. Laser beam welding, though currently restricted to thin materials, shows promise for future applications.

Electron Beam Welding

The electron beam process has revolutionized dissimilar metal joining through its high-density energy and rapid welding speed. This method effectively addresses thermal conductivity variations between different metals. The process creates extremely small weld zones without filler metal, minimizing intermetallic compound formation and making it ideal for many dissimilar metal combinations.

Flash Butt Welding

Flash butt welding produces exceptional quality joints between copper and aluminum. The process expels most molten metal from the joint, resulting in a solid-state connection. This technique proves particularly effective for joining rods, wires, bars, and tubes.

Arc Welding Applications

When specialized processes prove unsuitable, traditional arc welding methods offer reliable solutions for dissimilar metal joining. The three primary processes include:

1.   Shielded metal arc welding
2.   Gas tungsten arc welding
3.   Gas metal arc welding

Aluminum Welding Solutions

The significant difference in melting temperatures between aluminum (approximately 650°C) and steel (approximately 1538°C) presents a fundamental challenge in their joining. During welding, aluminum melts and flows away before steel reaches its melting point, complicating the joining process.

The aluminum-iron phase diagram reveals the formation of complex brittle intermetallic compounds. Iron-aluminum alloys containing more than 12% iron exhibit minimal to no ductility. Furthermore, substantial differences exist in the coefficient of linear expansion, thermal conductivity, and specific heats between aluminum and steel, resulting in significant thermal stresses during welding.

The most effective approach involves using an aluminum-steel transition insert, where each metal is welded to its corresponding base metal using standard arc welding processes. An alternative approach involves coating the steel surface with aluminum-compatible metals. The success of this method depends on the coating metal selection, coating thickness, and bond strength between the coating and steel surface.

For instance, zinc-coated steel can be welded to aluminum using gas tungsten arc welding with high-silicon aluminum filler wire. The process requires directing the arc toward the aluminum, with pulsing improving weld quality.

When joining aluminum to stainless steel, manufacturers can utilize transition inserts or coating techniques. Pure aluminum coating can be applied by dipping clean stainless steel into molten aluminum. Alternatively, stainless steel can be tinned with high-silicon aluminum alloy. The subsequent welding process should direct the arc toward the aluminum component. For aluminum-copper connections, these joints are best achieved using copper-aluminum transition insert pieces.

Copper Welding Applications

Copper and copper-base alloys can be successfully joined to mild, low-alloy, and stainless steels. For thin sections, gas tungsten arc welding with high-copper-alloy filler rod proves effective, particularly in pulsed mode. The arc should target the copper section to minimize iron contamination.

For thicker materials, the process requires initial overlay or buttering of steel with filler metal, followed by welding of the overlaid surface to copper. Careful control of penetration prevents brittle joint formation, and proper copper preheating is essential. Another effective method involves copper overlay with nickel-base electrodes. For thick materials, applying a second overlay layer is recommended. Thick copper requires preheating to approximately 540°C (1000°F).

The overlaid or buttered copper surface requires smooth preparation for uniform joint quality. Minimizing copper dilution with the nickel electrode is crucial. Welding process selection among shielded metal arc, gas tungsten arc, or gas metal arc depends on available equipment and material thickness. These techniques also apply to joining copper to stainless steel and brass to mild and low-alloy steels.

Nickel-Base Alloy Connections

Joining nickel-base alloys to steels requires appropriate filler materials (Monel or Inconel), suitable arc welding processes, and material-specific electrode selection.

Conclusion

Successful dissimilar metal welding requires careful consideration of material properties, proper process selection, and appropriate technique application. Understanding the fundamental principles and challenges enables optimal joint design and welding procedure selection for specific applications.