Corrosion of Carbon Steel

---

Introduction to Carbon Steel Corrosion

Carbon steel, accounting for approximately 85% of annual steel production worldwide, remains the backbone of industrial infrastructure despite its limited corrosion resistance. Its applications span marine installations, nuclear and fossil fuel power plants, transportation systems, chemical processing facilities, petroleum production, pipelines, mining operations, construction projects, and metal-processing equipment.

The economic impact of metallic corrosion reaches hundreds of millions of dollars annually. As carbon steels constitute the largest class of alloys in use, both in tonnage and cost, their corrosion presents a significant industrial challenge, spawning entire industries dedicated to developing protective systems.

Composition and Corrosion Resistance

Carbon steels typically contain less than 2% by weight of alloying elements. While these limited additions generally don't dramatically improve corrosion resistance, weathering steels represent an exception. Small additions of copper, chromium, nickel, and phosphorus can significantly reduce corrosion rates in specific environments.

Types of Corrosion

Atmospheric Corrosion

Atmospheric environments are classified as rural, industrial, or marine. Corrosion rates vary significantly based on factors including:

• Average yearly temperature
• Rainfall patterns
• Mean temperature
• Presence of acid rain
• Relative humidity
• Atmospheric pollutants

The corrosion process requires both oxygen and water, with even a thin adsorbed water film sufficient to initiate the process. Exposure time to moisture, particularly influenced by relative humidity, plays a crucial role in determining corrosion rates.

Aqueous Corrosion

Water exposure presents varying corrosion challenges depending on:

• Temperature
• Flow rate
• pH levels
• Solution composition

In acidic conditions, hydrogen evolution prevents protective film formation, while alkaline solutions promote protective films that reduce corrosion rates. Seawater corrosion, while similar in overall rate to freshwater, tends to cause more localized pitting due to higher electrical conductivity.

Table 1. Comparison of results under different type of exposure

Effects of alloy selection, chemical composition and alloy additions	Sea air	Freshwater	Alternately wet with seawater or Spray and dry	Continuously wet with seawater
Ferrous alloys	Pockmarked	Vermiform on cleaned bars	Pitting, particularly on bars with scale	Pitting, particularly on bars with scale
Wrought iron versus carbon steel	Steel superior to wrought and ingot irons	Iron and steel equal in low-moor areas	Low-moor iron superior to carbon steel	Low-moor iron superior to carbon steel
Sulfur and phosphorus content	Best results when S and P are low	Best results when S and P are low	Best results when S and P are low	Apparently little influence
Addition of copper	Beneficial: Effect increasing with copper content	Beneficial: 0.635% Cu almost as good as 2.185% Cu	Beneficial: 0.635% and 2.185% Cu much the same	0.635% Cu slightly beneficial: 2.185% Cu somewhat less so
Addition of nickel	3.75% Ni superior even to 2% Cu; 36% Ni almost perfect after 15-year exposure	3.75%Ni superior even to 2%Cu; 36%Ni excellent resistance	3.75%Ni beneficial usually more so than Cu: 36%Ni the best metal in the set	3.75% Ni slightly beneficial and slightly superior to Cu: 36% Ni the best metal in the set
Addition of 13.5% Cr	Excellent resistance to corrosion: cold blast metal perfect after 15-year exposure: equal to 36% Ni steel	Excellent resistance to corrosion: equal to 36% Ni steel	Subject to severe localized corrosion that virtually destroys the metal	Subject to severe localized corrosion that virtually destroys the metal
Behavior of cast irons	Excellent resistance to corrosion: cold blast metal superior to hot: no graphitic corrosion	Undergoes graphitic corrosion	Undergoes graphitic corrosion	Undergoes graphitic corrosion

Soil Corrosion

Soil corrosion severity depends primarily on:

• Soil composition
• Moisture content
• Oxygen availability
• Electrical conductivity
• Acidity levels
• Dissolved salt content

The corrosion rate can be expressed mathematically as Z = a·t^m, where Z represents weight loss or maximum pit depth, t is exposure time, and a and m are situation-specific constants.