Bainite Hardening of Steel: Part Two

---

Introduction to Bainite Hardening Applications

Bainite hardening has gained increased interest across various industrial applications in recent years. Beyond its established use in the bearing industry where salt bath quenching represents the current state of the art, numerous applications now demonstrate clear advantages over traditional martensitic hardening and tempering processes. The bainite hardening technique delivers higher yield strength at equivalent hardness levels compared to tempered steel, enhanced tensile stress capabilities, and produces beneficial compressive stresses at component surfaces.

The success of any bainite hardening application depends on careful material grade selection that considers wall thickness, component weight, and desired yield strength specifications. Additionally, cooling strategies must be optimized to minimize dwell time in salt bath systems, ensuring economic viability of the process.

Advanced Bainite Transformation Method

A comprehensive method for complete bainite hardening of steel components used in bearings and other load-carrying applications involves performing bainite transformation at temperatures just above the martensite formation temperature. This process transforms 25% to 99% of the austenite into bainite at the initial temperature, followed by a controlled temperature increase to accelerate transformation of the remaining austenite into bainite.

Figure 1: The percentage transformation of austenite into bainite, illustrating two heat-treating cycles with approximately the same hardness but significantly different transformation times

Figure 2: The percentage transformation of austenite into bainite, comparing two heat-treating cycles with identical transformation times but notably different hardness levels

Comparative Analysis of Heat Treatment Cycles

The temperature versus logarithmic time relationship demonstrates two distinct cycles achieving approximately 60 HRC hardness levels. The martensite start point (Ms) typically varies between 180°C and 280°C depending on steel alloy composition, while Bs denotes bainite transformation start and Bf indicates bainite transformation finish. Maximum hardness achievement requires temperatures close to the martensite start point, though this approach results in economically impractical transformation times.

The optimized approach performs bainite transformation slightly above the Ms point until 25% to 99% transformation occurs, with preferred ranges of 50% to 90% and most optimal results at 60% to 80% transformation. The remaining hardening proceeds at increased temperatures where transformation velocity accelerates to 100% completion. Temperature increases can be adjusted to ensure complete bainite transformation, with the fraction of bainite formed at higher temperatures showing minimal effects on final hardness.

Process Optimization for Enhanced Performance

An alternative application of this process focuses on increasing hardness for predetermined transformation times. Traditional processes operating at optimum temperatures for transformation velocity versus time consumption typically achieve 58 HRC hardness for complete bainite transformation. The enhanced approach performs bainite hardening at lower temperatures until achieving more than 50% transformation, preferably 60% to 80%, before increasing temperature to optimum levels. This methodology produces steel alloys with 60 HRC hardness using identical transformation times.

Practical applications demonstrate both reduced transformation time and increased hardness compared to traditional bainite hardening methods. Results also indicate improved structural stability, which proves essential for many critical applications.

Comprehensive Advantages and Limitations

The advantages and disadvantages of bainite hardening processes vary depending on specific applications, though several general principles apply consistently. Bainite consists of ferrite with fine carbide precipitations, resulting in reduced volume changes and smaller crystal lattice dimensions that minimize part distortion. Most applications eliminate the need for separate tempering processes, as bainitic materials naturally exhibit desirable surface compressive stresses significantly higher than those achieved through martensitic hardening.

Additional benefits include higher yield strength at equivalent hardness levels compared to tempered steel, superior tensile stress properties, and improved notch impact strength. The process also produces lower residual austenite content compared to martensitic hardening methods.

However, certain limitations must be considered. Extended dwell times can render the process economically unfeasible for some applications. Process parameters require careful adjustment to accommodate part geometry and material specifications. Finally, austempered materials typically cannot achieve the maximum hardness levels possible with martensitic hardened materials.

Figure 3: Advantages of bainite hardening over martensitic hardening processes

Industrial Implementation Considerations

Successful bainite hardening implementation requires comprehensive understanding of material behavior, process parameters, and economic factors. The bearing industry has demonstrated the viability of salt bath quenching systems for bainite hardening applications, providing a foundation for expansion into other sectors. Critical components subjected to fatigue loading particularly benefit from bainitic structures due to superior toughness and crack propagation resistance compared to martensitic alternatives.

The selection of appropriate steel grades must align with component geometry, loading conditions, and performance requirements. Wall thickness and component weight significantly influence cooling rates and transformation kinetics, necessitating customized approaches for different applications. Process optimization focuses on minimizing salt bath dwell time while ensuring complete transformation and desired mechanical properties.

Future Developments and Applications

The expanding interest in bainite hardening processes reflects growing recognition of their advantages for specific applications. As manufacturing requirements increasingly demand components with superior fatigue resistance, dimensional stability, and surface properties, bainite hardening offers compelling solutions. The technique's ability to produce components with enhanced mechanical properties while reducing distortion makes it particularly attractive for precision applications.

Continued development of process optimization techniques, including advanced cooling strategies and temperature control systems, will further improve the economic viability of bainite hardening. Integration with modern heat treatment equipment and process monitoring systems enables more precise control over transformation parameters, ensuring consistent results across production runs.