Dynamic Strain Aging of Steel: Part One

---

Introduction to Strain Aging Mechanisms

Strain aging represents a critical metallurgical phenomenon that significantly influences the mechanical properties of steel and other engineering materials. Two distinct types of strain aging mechanisms can be identified: static strain aging (SSA) and dynamic strain aging (DSA). Each mechanism operates through different temporal relationships with the deformation process, resulting in varied effects on material behavior.

Static strain aging refers to the hardening process that occurs in materials after they have undergone plastic deformation and are subsequently aged for a specific period. The strengthening effect results from the diffusion of solute atoms to dislocations during the aging period. This diffusion process leads to the formation of solute atmospheres around dislocations, which effectively pin the dislocations and restrain them from further movement upon reloading. These interactions consequently lead to a measurable increase in yield strength.

The enhanced yield strength occurs because a higher stress level becomes necessary to tear the dislocations away from their associated solute atmospheres. Beyond yield strength improvements, strain aging may also increase ultimate tensile strength, reduce material ductility, and raise the ductile-to-brittle transition temperature. In steel systems, the primary elements responsible for strain aging effects are carbon and nitrogen, owing to their significantly higher diffusivities as interstitial solutes compared to substitutional solutes.

Dynamic Strain Aging Temperature Effects and Material Behavior

The diffusivity of aging elements exhibits strong temperature dependence, making both aging temperature and aging time critical factors in determining the extent of strengthening achieved. Dynamic strain aging distinguishes itself from static strain aging through its temporal relationship with the deformation process. DSA represents a process where aging occurs sufficiently rapidly to take place during the actual straining operation, producing various types of inhomogeneous deformations.

In low alloy steels (LAS), dynamic strain aging occurs within the temperature range of 150-350°C, where stress-strain curves exhibit characteristic serrations. These serrations become most pronounced at approximately 250°C, though the exact temperature depends significantly on the applied strain rate. The relationship between strain rate and DSA temperature range connects directly to the ability of diffusing atoms to maintain pace with moving dislocations during deformation, allowing the formation of solute atmospheres around dislocations throughout the entire stress-strain response.

The Portevin-Le Chatelier Effect and Plastic Flow Instabilities

The plastic flow instability that develops within the dynamic strain aging temperature range manifests as discontinuous or serrated plastic flow in stress-strain curves. These irregularities were first comprehensively studied by Portevin and Le Chatelier in aluminum alloys, leading to the naming of this phenomenon as the Portevin-Le Chatelier effect (PLC). The effect represents one of two primary types of instabilities associated with strain aging, the other being the Lüders front phenomenon.

The Lüders front, observable in tensile specimens, appears as a delineation between plastically deformed and undeformed material sections. This front typically appears at one end of the specimen and propagates with constant velocity toward the other end when the crosshead velocity remains constant during testing. While the nominal stress-strain curve appears smooth during Lüders front propagation, the localization process is preceded by characteristic yield point behavior, featuring a stress peak followed by a rapid drop to a lower flow stress value.

The PLC effect presents itself either as a sequence of shear bands appearing sequentially with sometimes regular spacing, or as a set of propagating bands originating from a source at one specimen end. The resulting nominal stress-strain curve exhibits serrated characteristics with oscillating stress and plastic strain values. During these oscillations, the average stress may remain constant or increase either steadily or in discrete steps corresponding to band passage across the specimen length, indicating continuous strain hardening processes.

Classification of Dynamic Strain Aging Serration Types

Dynamic strain aging produces five distinct types of discontinuous plastic flow, designated as A, B, C, D, and E types, each characterized by specific stress-strain curve features and underlying deformation mechanisms.

Figure 1: The stress-strain curves illustrating the various types of serrations

A-type serrations represent periodic serrations resulting from repeated nucleation of shear bands at peak stress levels, followed by continuous band propagation along the gauge length in the straining direction. These locking serrations feature abrupt stress rises followed by drops below the general stress-strain curve level. A-type serrations occur in the low-temperature, high-strain-rate portion of the DSA regime.

B-type serrations appear as oscillations about the general stress-strain curve level, occurring in rapid succession. These serrations result from narrow shear band nucleation at peak stress, with bands either propagating discontinuously or remaining stationary. At subsequent stress peaks, additional shear bands nucleate either in adjacent sections or at distances from previous bands. B-type serrations can evolve from A-type serrations at higher strain values or may appear immediately with plastic flow at higher temperatures and lower strain rates.

C-type serrations manifest as stress drops occurring below the general flow curve level and are attributed to dislocation unlocking mechanisms. These serrations appear at higher temperatures and lower strain rates compared to A and B-type serrations.

D-type serrations create plateaus in stress-strain curves, also termed "staircase type" serrations, which result from shear band propagation without work hardening or strain gradients ahead of moving bands. D-type serrations may also occur in combination with B-type behavior.

E-type serrations share similarities with A-type serrations but do not produce work hardening during band propagation. These plastic flow instabilities develop from A-type behavior at high strain values.

Testing Conditions and Serration Observation

The observation of different serration types depends significantly on testing methodology. A, B, C, and E-type discontinuous plastic flow patterns are observed when tensile tests are conducted under constant extension rate testing (CERT) mode. In contrast, D-type serrations become observable when tests are performed under stress control mode, where loading either remains constant or increases at a constant rate.

The strain rate effect on DSA temperature range relates directly to the capacity of diffusing atoms to maintain synchronization with moving dislocations during deformation. This synchronization enables the formation of solute atmospheres around dislocations generated throughout the complete stress-strain response. Yield drops of up to 30% due to large amplitude serrations can be achieved in stress-strain curves under optimal DSA conditions.

Materials Susceptible to Dynamic Strain Aging

Beyond low alloy steels, several other materials relevant to light water reactor (LWR) applications are known to exhibit discontinuous deformation related to dynamic strain aging. Nickel-base alloys, including superalloys, demonstrate DSA effects due to carbon content and particularly under hydrogen-charged conditions. Austenitic stainless steels exhibit DSA behavior attributed to both interstitial and substitutional alloying elements. Zirconium alloys also show DSA effects due to the presence of hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen.

The understanding of dynamic strain aging mechanisms becomes particularly critical in nuclear reactor applications, where materials operate under elevated temperatures and stress conditions that can activate DSA processes. The resulting changes in mechanical properties, including increased yield strength but reduced ductility, must be carefully considered in component design and safety analysis.

Conclusion

Dynamic strain aging represents a complex metallurgical phenomenon that significantly influences the mechanical behavior of steel and other engineering materials. The process involves intricate interactions between solute atoms, dislocations, and applied stress-strain conditions, resulting in characteristic serrated flow behavior. Understanding these mechanisms proves essential for predicting material performance in high-temperature structural applications, particularly in nuclear reactor environments where DSA effects can substantially impact component reliability and safety margins.