Effect of Phosphorus on the Properties of Carbon Steels: Part Two

---

Enhanced Texture Properties and R-Value Performance

The anisotropy of plastic-flow properties serves as a crucial factor for determining the deep drawability of sheet steels used in automotive and manufacturing applications. Engineers measure drawability using the R-value, which represents the ratio of width to thickness strain in a uniaxial tensile specimen at a fixed extension of typically 17 percent. Values around 2.0 indicate excellent steel R-value deep drawability performance.

Phosphorus carbon steel properties become evident through crystallographic texture analysis, which relates directly to steel composition and processing parameters. In body-centered cubic materials like carbon steels, favorable drawing textures consist of a high proportion of {1 1 1} planes aligned parallel to the sheet surface. The influence of phosphorus on texture and R-value demonstrates complex interactions that vary with steel type and processing conditions.

Early investigations revealed that phosphorus additions up to 0.04% can significantly improve the R-value in low-carbon rimmed steel during decarburizing open-coil annealing processes. Hu's research documented improvements in R-value from approximately 1.5 to 2.0 with phosphorus carbon steel properties ranging from 0.004% to 0.12% in vacuum-melted rimmed steels subjected to simulated batch annealing.

Al-killed steels that undergo air melting show less dramatic improvements in steel R-value deep drawability, with performance appearing to plateau around 0.08% phosphorus content. Research suggests that phosphorus segregation at grain boundaries influences the nucleation and growth of recrystallized grains, thereby altering the recrystallized texture in Al-killed steel compositions.

Figure 1: Effect of heating rate on R-value as a function of phosphorus content and carbide morphology in Al-killed steel

Recent studies by Ono and colleagues emphasize the significance of heating rates during annealing processes for optimizing phosphorus carbon steel properties. Low-phosphorus steels containing 0.016% phosphorus exhibit maximum R-value performance in relation to specific heating rates. At optimal heating rates of approximately 50°C per hour, high-phosphorus steel demonstrates lower R-value performance compared to low-phosphorus steel, while the relationship reverses at heating rates exceeding 80°C per hour.

Hutchinson's research concluded that phosphorus provides benefits primarily when dissolved carbon would otherwise degrade texture quality. The phosphorus must segregate during slow heating processes to achieve effectiveness in improving steel R-value deep drawability. In Ti-stabilized ultra-low carbon steels, where minimal carbon exists in solution during annealing, small phosphorus additions consistently enhance R-value performance.

Figure 2: The figure illustrating R-value as a function of grain size for rapidly annealed, Ti-stabilized, ultra-low carbon steels containing Si, Mn, or P

Optimized Spot Weldability Characteristics

Carbon steel spot weldability research conducted by Sawhill and Baker compared resistance spot-welding characteristics between plain-carbon steel and rephosphorized steel containing 0.04% to 0.12% phosphorus. Their findings demonstrated that adequate weld button size, strength, and toughness could be achieved across practical ranges of welding conditions with proper parameter adjustments.

Manufacturing processes require slight increases in electrode face diameter and welding times compared to plain-carbon steels when working with phosphorus-enhanced materials. Additional studies confirm excellent carbon steel spot weldability in rephosphorized Al-killed steel and galvannealed Ti-stabilized ultra-low carbon steels, provided phosphorus content remains below 0.1% for optimal performance.

Enhanced Magnetic Properties and Core Loss Reduction

Steel magnetic core loss applications benefit significantly from phosphorus additions to cold-rolled motor-lamination steels, typically incorporating up to 0.15% phosphorus content. A substantial portion of core loss originates from eddy currents, which demonstrate inverse relationships with electrical resistivity in steel compositions.

Phosphorus enhances electrical resistivity in steel, effectively reducing eddy currents and improving steel magnetic core loss performance in electrical applications. The addition of phosphorus simultaneously enhances the punchability of motor laminations, contributing additional utility for manufacturing processes requiring precise dimensional control.

Advanced Coating Behavior and Galvannealing Performance

Galvannealed coating behavior experiences significant influence from phosphorus content in low-carbon aluminum-killed steels. Phosphorus retards alloy layer formation during galvannealing processes, which can provide benefits when galvannealing temperatures receive appropriate adjustments to maintain production efficiency.

Precise control of phosphorus levels remains essential for optimizing galvannealed coating behavior and processing parameters. Phosphorus effectively inhibits the "outburst reaction" at grain boundaries, which contributes to poor powdering performance associated with brittle Fe-Zn intermetallic compounds in coating applications.

Figure 3: The effects of phosphorus on formation of Fe-Zn compounds outburst structure

Steels containing phosphorus content exceeding 0.04% can prevent embrittlement from zinc penetration during heating processes, as phosphorus segregation inhibits intergranular diffusion mechanisms. This characteristic proves particularly valuable for automotive applications requiring superior coating performance.

Phosphatability improves significantly with 0.07% phosphorus additions to niobium-bearing ultra-low carbon steel compositions. Phosphorus enhances corrosion resistance in phosphated steel applications and improves fishscaling resistance along with after-fire strength in specialized enameling steels. However, inconsistent phosphorus levels can create process control challenges during production operations.

Comprehensive Performance Optimization

The research demonstrates that phosphorus carbon steel properties play critical roles in influencing texture, drawability, spot weldability, magnetic properties, and coating behaviors across diverse applications. Proper management of phosphorus levels can yield significant performance improvements in automotive, electrical, and manufacturing applications.

Steel R-value deep drawability benefits from phosphorus additions when combined with appropriate processing parameters, making phosphorus unique among alloying elements for simultaneously increasing both strength and formability. Carbon steel spot weldability remains excellent with phosphorus content below 0.1%, while steel magnetic core loss applications benefit from higher phosphorus levels up to 0.15%.

Galvannealed coating behavior requires careful phosphorus control to optimize processing parameters while maintaining coating quality and production efficiency. Ongoing research continues to clarify phosphorus's complex interactions in steel properties, providing manufacturers with improved understanding for optimizing steel compositions and processing parameters.

The comprehensive analysis reveals that phosphorus serves as an essential element in modern steel manufacturing, offering unique combinations of strength, formability, and specialized properties that meet demanding application requirements across multiple industries.