Selection and Weldability of Non-Heat-Treatable Aluminum Alloys

---

Understanding Non-Heat-Treatable Aluminum Alloys

Non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys represent a specialized group of materials that derive their strength properties exclusively through cold work and solid solution strengthening mechanisms. These alloys fundamentally differ from their heat-treatable counterparts because they lack the capability to form second-phase precipitates that would otherwise enhance their strength characteristics. Consequently, non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys cannot achieve the exceptionally high strengths that characterize precipitation-hardened materials.

However, the absence of precipitate-forming elements in these low- to moderate-strength non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys becomes a significant advantage when evaluating their weldability. Many alloy additions required for precipitation hardening, such as copper combined with magnesium or magnesium paired with silicon, can create problematic conditions during welding, including liquation and hot cracking phenomena.

The superior weldability of non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys extends beyond reduced cracking susceptibility. These materials exhibit higher joint efficiencies because the heat-affected zone remains largely uncompromised by precipitate coarsening or dissolution processes that plague heat-treatable alloys. This characteristic eliminates the necessity for thick joint lands or postweld heat treatment procedures, making welded structures viable in their as-welded condition.

Alloy Classification and Industrial Applications

Non-heat-treatable wrought aluminum alloys can be systematically categorized into four distinct groups according to standard Aluminum Association designations, each serving specific industrial applications based on their unique properties.

1xxx-Series Alloys: Commercial Purity Applications

The 1xxx-series alloys maintain commercial purity levels exceeding 99% aluminum content and find primary application where thermal conductivity, electrical conduction, or corrosion resistance takes precedence over strength requirements in design considerations. Alloy 1100 exemplifies this category, serving extensively in sheet metal work, fine stock production, and chemical equipment manufacturing. For specialized electrical applications, alloys with purity levels exceeding 99.5%, such as alloy 1350, are specifically utilized for electrical conductor applications.

3xxx-Series Alloys: Enhanced Strength and Formability

The 3xxx-series alloys address applications requiring additional strength and formability while maintaining excellent corrosion resistance characteristics. Alloy 3004 represents a typical example, finding widespread use in sheet metal work, storage tank construction, and beverage container manufacturing. These alloys derive their enhanced strength through cold work processes and fine (Mn, Fe)Al6 dispersoids that effectively pin grain and subgrain boundaries. Additional strengthening occurs through solid solution mechanisms involving both manganese and magnesium elements. Common applications encompass cooking utensils, pressure vessels, and building products including siding and gutters.

4xxx-Series Alloys: Specialized Welding Applications

Apart from their critical role as welding filler material, 4xxx-series alloys demonstrate limited industrial application in wrought form, making them primarily valuable for joining operations rather than structural applications.

5xxx-Series Alloys: High-Strength Applications

The 5xxx-series alloys serve applications demanding higher strength levels, achieved through substantial magnesium quantities maintained in solid solution. More significantly, magnesium promotes work hardening by reducing stacking fault energy, thereby diminishing the tendency for dynamic recovery processes. Industrial applications for 5xxx-series alloys include automobile and appliance trim, pressure vessel construction, armor plate manufacturing, and components designed for marine and cryogenic service environments.

While these alloys typically demonstrate good corrosion resistance, careful processing attention is required to prevent continuous β-Mg3Al2 precipitate formation at grain boundaries, which can lead to intergranular corrosion. This phenomenon can occur in heavily cold-worked, high-magnesium alloys exposed to temperatures ranging from 120 to 200°C. Alloy 5454 possesses the highest magnesium content suitable for sustained elevated temperature exposure and has become the standard material for truck bodies in hot oil or asphalt applications, as well as storage tanks for heated products.

Filler Alloy Selection Strategies

Filler alloys used for joining non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys can be selected from three primary alloy groups, with commonly used options including 1100, 1188, 4043, 4047, 5554, 5654, 5183, 5356, and 5556. The optimal filler alloy selection for any given application depends on desired performance characteristics related to weldability, strength, ductility, and corrosion resistance.

Generally, the selected filler alloy should maintain compositional similarity to the base metal alloy. Therefore, 1xxx filler alloys are recommended for joining 1xxx- or 3xxx-series base metal alloys. However, exceptions to this guideline occur when weldability concerns become paramount. The weldability of non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys can be evaluated through their resistance to hot cracking and porosity formation.

Hot Cracking Considerations

Hot cracking problems emerge when welding under highly constrained conditions or when working with alloys particularly susceptible to cracking phenomena. Similar challenges may arise when 1xxx fillers are used to join 5xxx alloys or vice versa, or when welding dissimilar metal combinations such as alloys 1100 and 5083, where mutual dilution may result in problematically low magnesium levels. Electron-beam welding or laser-beam welding can also produce cracking when magnesium, a high-vapor-pressure alloying element, is vaporized during the process. This problem becomes more severe when welding in vacuum environments.

When hot cracking persists despite other measures, utilizing 4xxx fillers provides an alternative approach. These aluminum-silicon alloys demonstrate exceptional cracking resistance, attributed partly to their abundant liquid eutectic availability for back-filling operations.

Porosity Management

Non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys exhibit susceptibility to hydrogen-induced weld metal porosity, a characteristic shared with aluminum alloys generally. This porosity develops during solidification due to the abrupt decrease in hydrogen solubility when transitioning from liquid to solid states. Porosity can be most effectively prevented by minimizing hydrogen pickup during welding operations.

Weld Properties and Performance Characteristics

When non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys undergo welding, microstructural damage occurs within the heat-affected zone. Unlike heat-treatable alloys, whose strengthening precipitates may dissolve or coarsen, the HAZ damage in non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys is limited to recovery, recrystallization, and grain growth processes. Consequently, strength loss in the HAZ is significantly less severe than that experienced in heat-treatable alloys. This characteristic makes 5xxx-series alloys popular for welded pressure vessel applications where reasonable joint strengths can be achieved in the as-welded condition without requiring post-weld heat treatment.

The weld metal of non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys typically represents the weakest component of the joint and becomes the failure location when the joint experiences loading. This contrasts with most heat-treatable aluminum alloys, where the heat-affected zone often constitutes the weakest link. The weld metal microstructure of non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys consists of columnar-dendritic substructures containing interdendritic eutectic constituents, primarily (Fe, Mn)Al6 for 1xxx and 3xxx alloys, and Mg3Al2 for 5xxx alloys.

Military and Defense Applications

An important application for alloy 5083 involves the construction of tactical military vehicles. The hulls and turrets of vehicles including the M113 armored personnel carrier, M2/M3 infantry and cavalry fighting vehicles, M109 self-propelled howitzer, and AAV7A amphibians all consist of welded 5083 aluminum structures. Additionally, numerous brackets, clips, and other components are welded to the hulls and turrets, although these are not typically fabricated to meet ballistic requirements.

The selection of alloy 5083 for these critical defense applications demonstrates the superior weldability and structural integrity achievable with non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys in demanding service environments where reliability and performance are paramount.